The Camera On The Time Clock Was Security Theatre
Warehouse staff were clocking each other in and out with shared PINs, so management wanted a camera to photograph everyone who logged in. Nobody was going to review the photos. Within days, the camera was covered in permanent marker.
Years ago I put together a time tracking system for the warehouse staff.
It was simple. A terminal on the wall. You put in your PIN, then selected what you were doing: start day, end day, lunch, and so on. That was the whole thing.
Shared PINs
The problem was not the software. It was the PINs.
People shared their codes. Once you knew someone else’s PIN, you could clock them in and out. So someone running late could get a coworker to clock them in on time, and someone leaving early could get a coworker to clock them out later.
The records looked fine. They just were not true.
Management Wanted A Camera
Management’s answer was a camera.
Every time someone logged in at the terminal, it would take a photo. If you clocked in as someone else, there would be a picture of your face next to their name.
The catch was that nobody was going to look at the photos. There was no plan for anyone to review them, compare them against the names, or follow up on the ones that did not match. They would just be taken and stored.
It was security theatre.
The camera was there to look like something was being done, not to actually catch anyone.
Permanent Marker
A few days after the camera went in, someone put permanent marker over it.
We cleaned it off.
Then the plastic over the camera got scratched up.
After that, nobody bothered. The camera stayed on the wall, scratched and useless, and people kept sharing PINs.
It Was Never A Software Problem
The people clocking each other in knew exactly what they were doing. A camera did not change that, and neither would a better terminal.
Staff were covering for each other because nobody was dealing with the person who turned up late or left early. That is a conversation a manager has to have with someone. It is not a feature request.
The camera let everyone skip that conversation. There was a device on the wall, so it looked like the problem had been handled, and nobody had to talk to anybody.
No technology was going to fix it, because the problem was never in the technology.